Chapter 8 - The Hidden Sister
The red and blue emergency lights spun against the wet trees for nearly three hours as state investigators processed the scene.
Tobias worked alongside the troopers, showing them the false backing in the pantry, the hidden casing in the wall, and the open shaft behind the carriage shed. Simone stood on the porch with Agent Miller, reviewing the carbon-copy pharmacy receipts and the forged transfer waivers.
It was nearly midnight when a yellow compact car turned slowly into the driveway, its headlights illuminating the sea of police vehicles.
The car stopped behind Simone’s sedan.
The driver’s door opened, and my younger sister, Faye, stepped out into the cold night.
She wasn't wearing her usual designer clothes or the smug, self-satisfied expression she had worn at the reading of the will. She was wearing an oversized college hoodie and sweatpants. Her mascara was smeared down her cheeks, and she was clutching a leather binder to her chest as if it were a life preserver.
She saw the troopers. She saw the yellow crime scene tape across the porch.
She stopped in her tracks, trembling so violently that her keys fell from her hand and clattered against the gravel.
“Della?” she called out, her voice childlike, stripped of all its usual condescension.
I walked down the porch steps, the cold air biting through my sweater. Tobias followed two paces behind, keeping a watchful, silent vigil.
“What are you doing here, Faye?” I asked.
Faye looked past me at the open front door, then at the tire tracks left by the state police cruisers that had already transported Mom to the county holding facility.
“Mom called me from the road before they took her phone,” Faye sobbed, the tears cutting fresh tracks through her makeup. “She told me to go to her house. She told me to take the floor safe in her bedroom closet, drive to the airport, and buy a ticket to Miami.”
I stared at her. “And did you?”
Faye held out the leather binder with shaking hands. “I opened the safe, Della. I wanted to see why she was so panicked.”
She stepped forward, dropping onto her knees on the wet gravel at the base of the porch steps. She held the binder up toward me like an offering.
“She lied to me, Della,” Faye wept, her voice breaking into ragged gasps. “The hundred and ninety thousand dollars... she didn't leave that to me from Grandma’s account. Mom took out three high-interest private commercial loans using my social security number and my name as the primary guarantor. She forged my signature on twenty-six commercial development notes with Vance Engineering!”
Simone walked down the steps, taking the binder from Faye’s hands. She flipped through the first five pages using her pen light, her expression growing darker with every second.
“Faye is telling the truth,” Simone said quietly to me. “Eileen didn't give Faye an inheritance. She used Faye as an unvetted borrower to draw down capital against the property before the title could be cleared. Faye isn't an heir to an estate. She is personally liable for two point four million dollars in commercial default debt to Blackwood Partners.”
I looked down at my sister. The golden child. The sister who had laughed when Mom handed me a crumbling house and called it all I deserved.
Faye looked up at me from the dirt, entirely destroyed. “She used both of us, Della. She was going to leave me with the debt, and she was going to leave you with the demolished ruins.”
I knelt down in the cold gravel until I was eye-level with her.
For years, I had dreamed of this moment—dreamed of seeing Faye realize that our mother’s love was a transaction, a toxic illusion built on cruelty. But looking at her now, shivering in the mud, I didn't feel triumph.
I felt an ancient, profound grief for the family we were supposed to have been.
“Get up, Faye,” I said softly.
Faye choked on a breath. “You... you don't hate me?”
“I’m angry at you,” I said, helping her pull herself up from the wet stones. “I’m furious that you stood by and watched her humiliate me for twenty years. But you’re my sister. And right now, the only way either of us survives what Mom did is if we tear down her lies together.”
Faye buried her face in my shoulder, sobbing with an intensity that shook her entire body. I held her for the first time since we were children, while behind us, the old timber house stood tall against the night sky, scarred but unyielding.
Tobias stepped down beside us, his voice quiet in the darkness.
“Della,” he said, looking toward the open front door where the interior lights were still burning. “Agent Miller found something else in the wall behind the pantry.”
I pulled back from Faye, wiping the cold dampness from my face. “What did she find?”
“It wasn't a document,” Tobias said, his dark eyes glowing with a strange, fierce intensity. “Florence didn't just hide ledgers. She hid the original physical bearer share certificates for the Monongahela River Logging Corporation from nineteen forty-two.”
Simone’s head snapped up from the loan documents. “Bearer shares? Those were never redeemed when the mill shut down?”
“Never,” Tobias said. “And under the co-op charter, whoever holds those physical certificates doesn't just own the timber rights. They own the water utility easements for the entire commercial corridor from here to the Ohio River.”
May you like
Simone let out a breathless laugh. “That means Blackwood Partners doesn't own the development corridor. Della does.”
***